"Why?" ~Why Guy to Try Guy when he tried to explian to him why he has to kill the Mario Bros.
These are some of the most annoying Shy Guys ever. They like to ask questions up to the point of where you get mad at them and want to kill them. The only problem is that their questions actually have a magical effect that makes you physically weak. These Shy Guys are cousins of Who Guys, When Guys, What Guys and Where Guys. Why Guys are the only ones in this group of five that don't experience memory loss ever.